Looking into the future the Pelican feeding its young from a self-induced wound in its own
breast (as depicted, mysteriously, on the state flag of Louisiana) is accepted as an
appropriate symbol of both self-sacrifice and rebirth. Through his selfless efforts, man is
raised from the slavery of ignorance to the condition of freedom conferred by wisdom.
Given the current state of affairs in Louisiana, one hopes that the understanding of the Pelican
as a symbol shall point the way towards a new consciousness of ourselves as a whole, and lead us
to face our futures with strength, grace, wisdom and faith, to learn from our mistakes and carry
our successes and zest for living to future generations.
Corps Post 1965 Hurricane Barrier Plans Would Not Have Saved New Orleans From Hurricane Katrina
How do we know the Corps plans would not have saved New Orleans?
Because Al Naomi, a senior project manager for the Corps, said the
levees and
control structures in the post-1965 plan were not big enough to control a surge and protect the city.
After Hurricane Betsy in 1965, plans developed by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to protect New Orleans from a strong
hurricane were short-sighted and flawed.
The orginal Hurricane Barrier Project(HBP), which was to be an extension of
the New Orleans levee system, was deemed
legally inadequate by Judge Charles Schwartz, Jr. in 1977. The Corps
of Engineers failed to follow up with an alternative plan or a proper Environmental
Impact Study (EIS) which was also sensitive to the environmental stability of Lake Pontchartrain.
In the same L.A. Times article that Mr. Naomi notes the inadequecy of the levees and barriers, former U.S. Army Corps of
Engineers Counsel Joe Towers makes a misleading
statement
which unjustly accuses co-plaintiffs St. Tammany Parish Police Jury and Save Our Wetlands of stopping the Corps' 1977
Hurricane
Barrier Project.
"If we had built the barriers, New Orleans would
not be flooded." It should be noted that it was ultimately the Corps' decision not to go ahead with the plan to build the
HBP and that Judge Schwartz's injunction would be lifted if the Corps could provide the proper EIS.
Furthermore, Mr. Towers makes an
untrue, wreckless and unjust statement
about Judge Charles Schwartz, Jr.:
"My feeling was that saving human lives was more important than saving a percentage of shrimp and
crab in Lake Pontchartrain," Towers said. "I told my staff at the time that this judge had condemned the city."
Considering what staff members from the Army Corps of Engineers just reported in the
United States Government Accountability Office Report on the Army Corps of Engineers
Lake Pontchartrain and Vicinity Hurricane Barrier Project, Mr. Towers may want to reconsider what he said about Judge Schwartz. When it seems entirely possible that
the Judge's decision to uphold the injunction has in fact saved an untold loss of property and human life.
Not only was the Corps of Engineers 1977 New Orleans District
Hurricane Barrier Project(HBP), a poorly concieved plan for
hurricane protection, it was also a scam to develop-drain
wetlands under the guise of Hurricane protection. This
HBP would have destroyed 28,000 acres of wetlands in
New Orleans East for the Orlandia subdivision. Therefore,
promoting development in hurricane tidal flood plains
under the ruse of hurricane protection, profiting wealthy
Texas oil barons, who owned this tract of New Orleans
East wetlands at the time.
It also would have created 100's of millions of
dollars for a particular dredging company, who was a
big time campaign contributor to U.S. Congressman F.
Edward Hebert, sponsor of this Pork Barrel bill. It
would not have saved New Orleans from Hurricane
Katrina.
The Corps refusal to fill in the Mississippi River
Gulf Coast Outlet(MRGO)
(see Mississippi River Gulf
Outlet, Land Loss, and the Threat of Hurricanes and
Mississippi River Gulf Outlet, the washout)
and Bush's refusal to properly fund a more adequate
structural levee protection system for New Orleans are the major culprits.
"During that time, appropriations have generally
declined from about $15-20 million annually in the earlier years to about $5-7
million in the last three fiscal years. While this may not be unusual given the
state of completion of the project, the Corps’ project fact sheet from May
2005 noted that the President’s budget request for fiscal years 2005 and 2006,
and the appropriated amount for fiscal year 2005 were insufficient to fund
new construction contracts." Source:
United States Government Accountability Office Report
on the Army Corps of Engineers Lake Pontchartrain and Vicinity Hurricane Barrier Project
See:
United States of Shame and
Politicians Failed Storm Victims
Another major villain are the hundreds of oil company
canals dug thru the wetlands of St. Bernard-Plaquemines Parishes.
The salt water erosion of these canals gave hurricane Katrina a deadly
highway thru Plaquemines Parish, St. Bernard Parish, New Orleans East,
Chalmette and on to the lower 9th ward of New Orleans.
See:
Canals and Channels are the Cause of Wetland Loss
and
Resolutions of Save Our Wetlands Inc. (SOWL)
SOWL is pushing for the state of Louisiana to sue the
oil companies for the 100's of billions of dollars of
damages their thousands of oil company canals have
reaped and eroded upon Louisiana's coastal line.
In 1977 the St. Tammany Parish Police Jury joined
with SOWL as plaintiffs to stop the Corps New Orleans
hurricane barrier project. One of St. Tammany Parish's
major concerns was that a force 4 or 5 major hurricane
would top the barriers, and the floodwaters would not
be able to flush back into the Gulf of Mexico.
It should also be noted that the taxpayers of New
Orleans voted overwhelmingly on two different
elections against funding this project in spite of the
huge political push by Guy Le Mieux, then president of
the Orleans Levee Board.
The plaintiffs proved that the Corps lied by
misrepresenting their own internal engineering report
in violation of the National Environmental Policy
Protection Act.
See:
Order- Judge Schwartz's Decision 1977
Because it would have affected the salinity and
veloicity flow of Lake Pontchtrain,the HBP would also
have destroyed the Lakes Maurepas Pontchtrain
Catherine Borgne(MPCB) eco system.
SOWL's injunction, which eventually resulted in
the halting of developing 28,000 acres of wetlands.
This land would have been used to create the extremely low-lying Orlandia
subdivision in New Orleans East. This action eventually saved the
wetlands, which are presently located in the Bayou
Sauvage National Wildlife Refuge Center. This is the
largest urban wildlife park in the world. And as
wetlands acted as a buffer-barrier to the tidal surges
of Hurricane Katrina This area was severely flooded by
Hurricane Katrina.
Imagine the additional destruction and loss of human
lives Hurricane Katrina would have caused, if Save
Our Wetlands Inc.(SOWL) had not enjoined this pork
barrel Hurricane Barrier Project scheme, which would
have resulted in a 28,000 acres Orlandia New Orleans East
wetlands- Texas oil barons flood plain hurricane-tidal
surge- housing development.
Also in 1974, the United States Army Corps of Engineers, New
Orleans Division, was engaged in criminally
diking-damning-permitting 5,200 acres of navigable
public owned Louisiana waterbottoms on the North
shores of Lake Pontchtrain in Slidell, Louisiana, St.
Tammaqny Parish.
See:
History of the Eden Isles, Oak Harbor & North Shore Estate subdivisions in Slidell Louisiana
In 1974, SOWL filed suit attempting to get a U.S.
Special Grand Jury investigation against the Corps for
illegally and criminally diking-damning Louisiana navigable
waterways, resulting in the Eden Isle Subdivision.
See:
Drained Wetlands: How Infirm a Foundation?
SOWL also requested a moratorium on all permits in
the Lakes MPCB eco-system until such time that a
proper regional cumulative environmental impact study
could be conducted under the National Environmental
Policy Act. If SOWL had obtained this study, there's a
possibility that Hurricane Katrina's damages could
have been hundreds of billions dollars less to the
American taxpayers, and the loss of life could have been less.
These continual illegal actions by the Corps in
cahoots with everybody from Louisiana's 1970's former Lieutenant
Governor & his law partners, the former St.
Tammany Parish District Attorney, the former Louisiana State
Attorney General William Guste to Governors Edwin
Edwards & Mike Foster to the Bush Savings Loan Scandal
U.S. Regional Trust Corp.(RTC) to the present St.
Tammany Parish Council has resulted in the disatrous destruction of the
Eden Isle-Oak Harbor-Lakeshore Estates subdivisions.
See:
Oak Harbor East Fight Continues with
Lawsuit and
Land Developers, Corps Ruin
Lake?
These billion dollar subdivisions, built smack dab in
the midst of a hurricane tidal surge, destroyed 5,200
acres of a vast Louisiana natural economic resource.
Hurricane Katrina greatly obliterated Eden Isle, Oak
Harbor and Lakeshore Estates.
And what was once the 5,200 acres of wetlands, which acted as a
flood buffer-barrier to the city of Slidell with a
population of 30,000 was also drained for these subdivisions. And therefore
the old historic town of Slidell has been devastated.
See:
City's Defenses Weakened, Ignored
Wetlands absorb and slow down incoming tidal surge like a sponge. Urban sprawl
such as subdivisions create a flat hard area where tidal surge just flows and flows further
inland unheaded. If an inadequate levee is also added to this urban sprawl then you get a
concrete bowl just like in New Orleans East where the water still sits.
See:
Letter:: June 12, 2004 to U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
Unfortunately now, Hurricane Katrina is forcing us as a nation and people to see and confront the lies and
actions of an ugly evil empire.
FAIR USE NOTICE: This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. Save Our Wetlands Inc.(SOWL) has no affiliation whatsoever with the originator of this article nor is Save Our Wetlands Inc.(SOWL) endorsed or sponsored by the originator. For more information go to:
www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.